The easiest answer is No. 7 Praxis. A bagel is chewy, a little salty and not sweet, so you want a coffee with chocolate and caramel sweetness and a touch of fruit to cut through the cream cheese. Praxis has dark chocolate, bright fruit and butterscotch notes, and it works with plain, sesame and everything bagels. For a milky latte on the side, reach for No. 3 Position. For a cinnamon raisin bagel, No. 5 Canela.
A note on how this works: there is no rule book for coffee and bagels. These are our picks from the tasting notes on each bag, not a lab result, and your toppings change the answer.
How do you match coffee to a bagel?
Think about three things.
- Sweetness. A bagel is mostly bread, so a coffee with natural sweetness (chocolate, caramel, butterscotch) fills in what the bread leaves out.
- Acidity. A bit of brightness cuts through cream cheese, butter and lox, the way lemon does with fish. Too much and it fights the salt, so keep it moderate.
- Body. A bagel with a thick schmear is heavy. A coffee with some weight stands up to it, and a very light cup gets lost.
| Bagel | What it needs | Our pick |
|---|---|---|
| Plain or sesame, with cream cheese | Sweetness and a little brightness | No. 7 Praxis |
| Everything, with butter or lox | Something that cuts salt | No. 7 Praxis |
| Egg and cheese sandwich, with a latte | Weight that holds up under milk | No. 3 Position |
| Cinnamon raisin or other sweet bagel | Flavor that matches the bagel | No. 5 Canela |
Which coffee goes with plain and everything bagels?
No. 7 Praxis. It is a medium roast from Antigua, Guatemala, with dark chocolate, bright fruit and butterscotch in the notes. The roaster describes it as the coffee for working out what you actually like, and it brews well any way you like. A bagel is a good test for it. Try it twice, once at 60 g per litre and once at 70, and keep whichever you preferred.
Our pick
No. 7 Praxis
Antigua, Guatemala · 1,200 to 1,616 m · Fully washed, sun dried · Bourbon, Catuai, Caturra, Typica · Medium
Dark chocolate, bright fruit and butterscotch, a good match for cream cheese and a salty topping.
Which coffee goes with a bagel sandwich and milk?
If your bagel has egg, cheese or meat and your coffee has milk in it, you need a coffee that does not disappear. The roaster recommends No. 3 Position for espresso, moka and anything you are going to put milk in. It is a wet-hulled coffee from Aceh, with dark chocolate, dried fruit and earthy notes. The roaster does not state a roast level for it, so we do not either. Brew it as espresso at 1:2 in 28 seconds, or in a moka pot.
Our pick
No. 3 Position
Aceh, Takengon, Indonesia · 1,100 to 1,600 m · Wet-hulled (giling basah) · Tim Tim, Typica, Ateng, Onan Ganjang, Jember
Dark chocolate, dried fruit and earthy notes, and it holds its shape under milk.
What goes with a cinnamon raisin bagel?
No. 5 Canela is a flavored medium roast with a cinnamon roll note. Its ingredients are coffee and natural flavorings. It is made for cold mornings and the end of a meal, so it suits a sweet bagel better than a savory one. Brew it as drip or in a moka pot, a little coarser than usual. It is good with milk and, in the roaster's words, better than it sounds black.
Our pick
No. 5 Canela
Flavored coffee · Medium
A cinnamon roll note that matches a sweet bagel, brewed as drip or in a moka pot.
How should you brew it for a breakfast table?
Drip is the practical choice when there are bagels and several people. Our 10 cup and 12 cup measure posts have the grams for a full pot. For one or two people, pour-over takes five minutes and the ratio cheat sheet has the numbers. If you want to know what you are getting when you brew a coffee, see what body means in coffee.
If you have already read our post on coffee with pancakes, the logic is similar, but a bagel is saltier, so lean toward the brighter coffee.
You can browse all ten coffees, or set up a subscription (11% off, skip or cancel in one click) so the bag is on the counter before the bagels run out.
What about the cream cheese, lox and other toppings?
Toppings shift the pick a little. A thick layer of cream cheese is rich and slightly tangy, so a coffee with fruit notes sits well beside it. Smoked fish and capers are salty, and a sweeter cup balances them. Peanut butter or butter alone call for a cup with chocolate in it. Eggs and bacon are heavy, and that is where a darker, earthier coffee like Position earns its place. If you are unsure, use the table above and change one thing at a time.
Temperature is a small detail that helps. Hot bread and hot coffee tend to flatten each other, so let the cup rest a minute or two while the bagel cools. Coffee tastes sweeter as it drops from scalding to hot, and you will notice the fruit and chocolate in the notes more.
Start with Praxis and a plain bagel, and change one thing at a time.
Questions people ask
What is the best coffee for an everything bagel?
Something with sweetness and a little brightness to cut the salt and garlic. No. 7 Praxis, with dark chocolate, bright fruit and butterscotch notes, is our pick. Brew it as drip or pour-over and drink it black or with a splash of milk.
Should you drink black coffee or coffee with milk with a bagel?
Either works. With cream cheese, a bagel is already rich, so black coffee clears the palate. If you take milk, choose a coffee that holds its shape under it, like No. 3 Position, which the roaster recommends for anything with milk.
Does flavored coffee go with bagels?
It can, mainly with sweet bagels. A cinnamon raisin bagel and No. 5 Canela, which tastes like a cinnamon roll, are an easy match. With a savory bagel, we would choose an unflavored coffee.
Free printable
Keep the ratio chart on your fridge
One page with grams, level tablespoons and scoops for every cup size and for coffee makers from 2 to 14 cups. Leave your email and the download link appears right here.